Does Mind precede Matter?

The following chain of events began with a question posted in Substack which I could not resist.
"What are you made of - Mind or Matter? Which comes first?"

Applying what I had learned previously from the Upanishads about the 4 layers of the mind, I suggested the following:

The physical part of the mind, which forms as the brain develops, can only exist because of the brain. Therefore matter must precede mind.

But the awareness or consciousness, which is what survives the death of the body, already existed before the body was formed. Therefore that part of the mind surely precedes matter.

I thought I was being quite clever.

Gabriel, who had posed the question in the first place, came back with the following response.

"Agreed. Though I would go so far as to collapse the distinction. Maybe matter is the image of the localized mind?"

That was a startling thought which took me into exploration of an entirely different concept.

Is the world of maya that we live in really only a construct of our own mind? What are the implications for our day to day activities and in our interactions with the other beings we encounter in our maya?

I have examined the idea in my Blog essay for this week.

Read more



Saturn's Daughter

After posting last week's article about a wounded woman speaking her truth and splitting the illusion, I pondered about woundedness in general. My stunted observation had been that, while men appeared to shrug off woundedness, women were deeply affected by their wounds. This led me to wonder, do deeply wounded souls incarnate as women in order to be able to process their woundedness?

I posed the question to several women in my life. My daughter came back with a sharp rebuttal: "Do you think men are not wounded?"

That led us into an animated discussion which culminated in this week's article about woundedness and incarnation. The discussion also reminded my daughter that she had a library of thoughts filed in her mind awaiting release. They had not been published yet because they were not appropriate for her web pages which were work related. This event was the trigger for her to initiate a philosophical presence on Substack as Saturn's Daughter

She has given me permission to mirror her Substack posts in my Blog. So join me in welcoming Shanee Singam as my second invited Guest Author.

Guest Authors

Saturn's Daughter



Woundedness and the Choice of Incarnation

Watch the video summary

Reflecting upon last week's post about the wounded female speaking out and splitting the illusion, a thought occurred to me: Are all females wounded?

Or, more precisely, does a wounded soul choose to incarnate in a female body in order to process its pain? It was a question not meant to generalize or discriminate but to probe the deeper logic of embodiment - why we take birth as we do.

My daughter’s response was immediate and grounding: “All humans are wounded. You think men don’t carry wounds?”

That answer turned the key. Of course woundedness is universal. It is not gendered. But how that wounding expresses and is processed may differ depending on the vessel - male, female, or otherwise.

Each incarnation is an experiment in balance. Souls seem to oscillate between polarities, tasting the full range of human experience: activity and receptivity, assertion and nurture, reason and feeling, order and flow.

Gender, in this sense, is less a binary, more a tuning fork - each lifetime resonates to a slightly different set of frequencies along the multi-layered masculine–feminine spectrum. The body is simply the instrument through which the soul works out its harmonics.

Ancient mystic traditions often recognized this. Many cultures regarded the androgynous, the gender-fluid, or those born with either both or no genitalia as spiritually significant - as if they held within them the blueprint for integrating both halves of human duality. Perhaps, as my daughter suggested, such beings take on the complex task of healing both lines, masculine and feminine, within the collective psyche.

Wounds are not only personal; they are civilizational.

In patriarchal societies, the feminine, in both women and men, has been suppressed: the intuitive, the emotional, the relational, the earth-honouring. The result is centuries of psychic imbalance, producing both wounded women and wounded men - the former through oppression, the latter through emotional amputation.

In a matrilineal or egalitarian society, the reverse might occur. The masculine drive for independence, conquest, and identity could become the neglected pole. Every culture, in its extremes, generates its own shadow.

Thus, incarnation may be the soul’s way of participating in a larger evolutionary balancing act, to experience firsthand the side of the human story it once ignored or injured. The “black sheep” in every family or tribe might then be seen as the corrective agent, the soul assigned to heal the unhealed generational line.

If men and women appear to handle pain differently, it may not be because one feels more deeply than the other but because each is conditioned, biologically and socially, to process pain through different channels. The feminine psyche tends to turn inward, metabolizing sorrow through empathy, expression, and relational healing. The masculine psyche often turns outward, diffusing pain through action, humour, logic, or distraction.

Neither is superior; they are complementary mechanisms within the same species, and sometimes, within the same soul, across lifetimes.

Over time, the soul learns to blend these: to act with compassion, to feel with clarity. When the vessel (the feminine) and the oar (the masculine) move in rhythm, healing becomes wholeness.

In the end, woundedness may not be a flaw but the very engine of reincarnation, the friction that polishes the soul. As my daughter wisely said, there is no one way or another, just a sustained ebb and flow until resolution. The soul, tired of the machismo of one life, might next choose the open vulnerability of the feminine; and having healed that, return to embody the masculine with newfound tenderness.

Perhaps the goal is not to escape the wound but to understand it, to become the healer of both halves of humanity within oneself.

If incarnation is a dialogue, in this instance between wound and wisdom, then gender would be its syntax, the way the story gets told.

Each lifetime adds a new paragraph to that grand narrative, moving the collective toward integration, where masculine and feminine, strength and softness, vessel and oar, become one rhythm - the rhythm of the Whole healing itself through the individuals.



Truth Splits the World Open

Watch the video summary

A couple of days ago, my niece shared with me a poignant extract from a poem that had inspired her. In the poem “Käthe Kollwitz” from her The Speed of Darkness collectionMuriel Rukeyser had said:

“What would happen if one woman told the truth about her life? The world would split open.”

There is a quiet power in that image — the world splitting open under the force of truth. I have often thought that truth, when spoken from the depth of one’s being, doesn’t just reveal; it rends the veils we have so carefully woven around ourselves. It lets in light, and for a brief, trembling moment, everything false falls away.

Illusion wraps around us in many layers.

What we call reality is, to begin with, māyā (illusion). Yet within that vast illusion, each person builds further illusions of their own: comforting fantasies, self-serving narratives, curated lives, beautiful lies to mask the disarray beneath. It is a hall of mirrors, reflections within reflections, and soon we begin to mistake the shimmering for substance. The collective noise of these overlapping illusions floods our senses and drowns the quiet truth that lies buried within.

But for the one nursing grief, that noise offers no solace. The world’s chatter cannot drown the ache that demands to be heard. Pain has a brutal clarity; it refuses to participate in illusion. So when someone, weary of pretense, dares to speak the truth — unadorned, unvarnished — it is a shock of relief. The world splits open, and for a while, we breathe.

Yet that moment passes. Even truth, once spoken, can harden into another story, another identity, another illusion. The only lasting relief lies in seeing through it all, in realising that everything we perceive, every drama and disguise, every joy and despair, unfolds within māyā.

This realisation is not an escape from life but a deep reconciliation with it. To know that all is illusion is not to reject the world, but to hold it lightly, to dance with it without becoming entangled. Those who learn to live with māyā as one might live with a dream, aware, awake, yet participating, find a quiet fulfilment.

Otherwise, we are tossed endlessly by the tumults of illusion in all its variegation — chasing shadows, grieving phantoms, mistaking reflection for truth. But once even one person tells the truth, and the world splits open, perhaps we begin to see: the light that pours through the crack was always there.



Most Read Posts